Narrative Painting in the East and West: Structural Divergence and Contemporary Relevance
Abstract
This paper examines the similarities and differences between Chinese and Western narrative painting within the contemporary image-saturated cultural context, focusing on their visual language, structural logic, and cultural functions. It traces the distinct developmental trajectories of both traditions: Western painting evolved from religious narratives to individual expression, ultimately ceding dominance to abstraction, while Chinese narrative painting, influenced by philosophical and societal shifts, developed its own characteristics, particularly a strong secular and collective focus from the Song and Yuan dynasties onwards. The comparative analysis highlights key structural differences: Western painting often employs a fixed, dramatic moment and focal perspective, emphasizing individual heroes, whereas Chinese painting utilizes a flowing, multi-perspective “scenic stroll” approach and often depicts collective scenes. The paper also explores brief historical convergences, such as artistic exchanges during the Qing dynasty, and concludes by reflecting on the potential relevance of narrative painting in countering historical nihilism in the contemporary era, where abstraction prevails. The main critique points to a need for greater academic rigor, clearer research questions, and formal citations.
References
[1] Clement Greenberg page3 https;//www.yorku.ca
[2][Germany] Lessing:,translated by Ellan Frothingham,Dover ed,2005,p16
[3]Zong Baihua: Selected Works of Zong Baihua’s Aesthetics and Art, Henan Literature and Art Publishing House, 2009, p. 62
[4]groups of Baihua; Where to Find Beauty “Chongqing University Press, 2014, p. 83
[5]Frank Vigneron,The Chinese University of Hong kong Press, 2022,P16
[6]Shang Hui, “The Frozen Epic,” Guangxi Normal University Press, 2023, p. 10
[7]Shang Hui, “The Frozen Epic,” Guangxi Normal University Press, 2023, p. 11
